29 November 2021

The Rotten Harvest of the Francis-Beijing Compromise

https://aleteia.org/2021/05/26/chinese-authorities-arrest-bishop-priests-seminarians/#

Arrested in May 2021, Bishop Joseph Zhang Weizhu has not been seen or heard from in six months. Hoping to find some kind of workable arrangement with Beijing, Pope Francis signed the 2018 accord which afforded Beijing a voice (and presumably a veto) in Vatican selections for Chinese episcopal sees.


Three years later, there are still dozens of vacancies and the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) has continued its clampdown on dissent and dissenting clerics. And it has stepped up its intrusion into the affairs of church life.

The non-sanctioned or underground Catholic community has been effectively abandoned by the Vatican, though there's reason to believe it still receives some quiet support from the state-sponsored CPCA – the Beijing approved 'official' Catholic Church in China.

One would think that given the CCP's conduct, Francis would tear up the agreement. Beijing was worried about Catholicism as a Fifth Column operating to subvert the state. Francis did not envision Catholicism in such a capacity, however in order to assuage the fears of Beijing, he has now placed the Roman Catholic Church in a state of subjugation.

Controversy has swirled around Francis – some of it hype fomented by his enemies, some of it is valid. The China Accord may go down as the biggest stain on his papacy. It is veritable betrayal of Chinese Catholics.

Zhang's career straddles the period of Vatican-approved/Beijing rejected underground bishops and the new order. Zhang apparently refused to register after the 2018 accord and yet it would seem he received little support from the Vatican. Additionally one would have thought the 2018 accord would have 'grandfathered' in already appointed bishops, or made some other kind of provision for them, but apparently not. The details of the accord remain a secret but one struggles to find just where Beijing conceded much of anything. It would seem Francis almost wholly bent to the will of the CCP.

New Testament Christians are for obvious reasons opposed to Roman Catholicism but like it or not the plight of underground Catholics goes somewhat hand-in-hand with the underground Protestant Church in China.

The Protestant-Evangelical unregistered or underground Church has in some cases disgraced itself and destroyed its own testimony by collaborating with Western political interests and thus has played into the Fifth Column narrative which Beijing has feared and warned against. The officially sanctioned Three-Self Patriotic Churches have simply bowed to Beijing and are viewed by the Protestant underground as apostate.

The underground Catholic Church on the other hand has been all but abandoned by its own hierarchy.

And thus the CCP is emboldened and the clampdown on underground churches will affect not just Catholics, but Protestants – even those who have refused to ally with Western Dominionist theology and the American Right. And it would seem, things are about to get a lot worse.

We need to pray for the Church in China but unfortunately American Christians are lining up with the likes of ChinaAid's Bob Fu and others – their actions only further politicising the Church's plight in China and tying it directly to the US Empire and its allies – the same forces that even now are preparing for war against Beijing. It's tragic but many Western Christians would actually support such a war and believe it to be the task of Western nations and empires to 'liberate' the Church as if such a thing were possible. And as a consequence the identity of the Church is confused and subsumed and its testimony destroyed. Pray, but make sure your prayers aren't postured as pro-America and Anti-China. We're citizens of Zion and all the nations of the world are Babylons, their evil is only differentiated by degree. No one will weep when the CCP falls, but neither should we cheer on the wicked schemes and bloodlust of Western nations which (despite the veneer they've been given by some) do not represent Christ's Kingdom in any shape or form.

See also:

https://pilgrimunderground.blogspot.com/2016/10/the-investiture-controversy-in-china.html

https://pilgrimunderground.blogspot.com/2018/03/a-jesuit-commentary-on-chinese.html

https://pilgrimunderground.blogspot.com/2016/12/underground-catholics-in-china.html

https://pilgrimunderground.blogspot.com/2020/07/the-sino-vatican-agreement-error-of.html

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.