The authoritarian states of Central Asia want conformity. They don't want anything subversive. They don't want subcultures. They want stability.
As such they aggressively pursue Salafism and other radical forms of Islam. Islam is the cultural default and as such it receives support from the state - which in turn monitors activity. Nothing radical is permitted. These states clamp down on Salafism just as they do anything that upsets the status quo.
Eastern Orthodoxy has a cultural pedigree so it is tolerated.
But they don't like Evangelicals because they are perceived as Western and will bring not only Western contacts and money into the country - and potential subversion, but also ideals which will subvert the stable order. I wish I could say the gospel was one of these ideals but these states are less worried about that, and more concerned the Evangelical converts will bring in things like feminism and agitation in the name of democratic rights - giving Western powers a foothold in terms of diplomatic pressure.
In this case the persecution is directed at Seventh Day Adventists. This particular group (and there are many within the SDA orbit) advocates conscientious objection akin to the Watchtower Society or the Anabaptists. The powers that be don't want people expressing opposition to military conscription as it will potentially lead others to question the narratives of the state and/or seek membership in the sect in order to avoid legislated military duty.
Like Russia, the Central Asian states do not like 'sects'. They want culturally safe and established religious bodies. Sects are subversive. Sects set up a counter-culture.
I always find this interesting because Western Evangelicals and Confessionalists are also (generally speaking) hostile to the sect idea. That was (they would argue) the problem with Fundamentalism. They want to be mainstream, out on the high street with a proper church building - preferably one that has a steeple that towers over the other buildings around it. Sects meet in store-fronts and on back streets. They meet in homes and basements and out of the way places.
And yet they will always express sympathy for sects within these international contexts even through they would reject the ethos in their own culture.
Additionally these Western Evangelicals will extend great sympathy for conscientious objectors in places like Kyrgyzstan, Russia, or China, but are all but contemptuous of such non-violent and nonconformist expression when it comes to the West, and in particular the United States. In the West a military record is celebrated and often associated with a form of piety.
As such I find their sympathy for these groups to be superficial and politically motivated as opposed to a genuine sense of Spirit-wrought camaraderie or fellowship.
While the Adventists certainly hold to erroneous doctrines, on this point, this particular group is correct and contrary to Evangelicalism, the sect model is in fact the New Testament ideal.
The persecution in Kyrgyzstan is actually (in New Testament) terms pretty normative and I contend that Western Christians would experience far more persecution if they were faithful on these points - the sect ideal which entails a refusal to register with the state and a rejection of civic duties (so-called), which includes not only military conscription, but sitting on a jury as well as voting. Additionally, faithful Christians are more likely to find themselves economically marginalised as Kingdom ethics will preclude their participation in many aspects of mainstream life.
For my part I will pray for the Christians in Central Asia - that more will have the testimony of this group in Kyrgyzstan and that they will resist the false teachings and ethics of Western Evangelicalism.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.