The Sacralist model of the Church has never been much for Church Discipline... that is with regard to those who at least nominally hold to the paradigm.
If you reject it, then in the Sacralist system you're a
theological and socio-political threat and when given the political ability,
the Sacralist powers both Roman Catholic and Protestant were and are quite
eager to destroy you.
But generally speaking if you're not too immoral and you
don't speak or campaign against the paradigm you can remain in good standing.
Rome's 'Big Tent' approach to catholicity has on the one
hand pulled off an amazing feat. They have managed to keep together a massive
institution with widely divergent beliefs and power-centers. The tent is so big
it's in danger is disintegration. The margins are so wide, that the centralised
power in Rome has trouble enforcing any kind of standard with regard to
doctrine and morality.
Many are arguing it has gone too far. There has to be a
correction. Benedict XVI tried to start the course of action and met massive
resistance and in the process began to discover just how dirty, corrupt and
wicked the Roman Entity really is.
There's a fear in tightening the noose, in beginning to
enforce discipline. Joe Biden is obviously not a Christian. He's a wicked man
on many fronts and yet still 'could' be a 'good Catholic'.
But he's not even that and in addition to his embrace of
American heresies, lies and militarism he's a Sodomite.
He may not personally engage in such practices but he
approves of them, celebrates them and encourages their practice. He is under
the same judgment according to Romans 1.
The provided link argues something must be done. He has to
be called out and challenged. He must be formally disciplined. His continuation
as a Catholic in good standing makes a mockery of the Church's Authority.
Americanism which is the religion of most Catholics and
Protestants in the United States chafes against religious and ethical authority
or any authority outside the self. People don't want to be told they're sinners
in need of repentance, they don't want to be told their wrong and refuse to
accept that they can't do whatever they feel is best... regardless of Church
doctrine. They don't want to be told they don't get to decide everything.
Catholicism doesn't have much of a leg to stand on at this
point. The appeal is made to the authority of a long tradition. Well, it only
takes a few moments of inquiry to learn the narrative doesn't hold up very well
and the organisation is riddled with hypocrisy on a scale that surpasses even
the worst of governments and corporations... of which Rome is both.
If Rome stands up to Americanism and begins to challenge its
premise by disciplining someone like Biden there's a real warranted fear that
the backlash against the hierarchy will be fierce.
Catholicism is in a slow decline but even those numbers are
somewhat misleading. Most Catholics aren't attending church and the majority of
them do not adhere to Catholic teaching. It's rare to find someone who does. In
addition they are in a crisis with regard to the priesthood. They cannot get
enough young men to sign up. They laicisiation of Roman parishes also breaks
down authority. Rome may not ordain women, but it's a lot of older women who
are essentially running local parishes.
There's a growing anger and frustration with Rome regarding
its official positions and the numerous scandals. Financially Rome is paying
out millions of dollars to abuse victims leading to the closing of many dioceses.
The long-term demographics are not positive. Rome is
following the same pattern exhibited in Protestantism... their young people are
walking away and not coming back.
If Rome begins to assert its authority it will probably see
a mass exodus but if it continues to let people like Biden flaunt its
authority, then Rome's authority is destroyed and eventually it will become a
meaningless organisation that allows people to pursue their own spirituality
while trying to funnel money into helping the poor etc...
At this point many Catholics stay in the bosom of Rome due
to tradition and superstition. They have abandoned its authority and as long as
the hierarchy stays docile, they'll stay in and nominally participate. But if
Rome starts to demand compliance, then many of these same nominal Catholics
will jump ship.
The fall of Rome is not something I lament but it's
interesting to watch.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.