John McCain has died and has (most likely) gone to hell. But as is so often
the case the world doesn't see it that way and they pay tribute to one that
served the Beast they all clamour to worship.
Is it not ironic that the so-called 'Liberal' media not only
lavishes praise on McCain and calls him a 'war hero' but all seem to forget his
record of endless warmongering and militarism? Über-nationalism and militarism
are suddenly values of the 'Left'? I guess it could be if you live in the degenerate
fantasy world of Dinesh D'Souza but for those who are interested in actual
thought, political or otherwise this seems problematic.
Or is it that the American 'Left' doesn't actually disagree
with McCain's posturing? The so-called 'Leftist' media has in fact long been a
champion of American militarism. On many points it's not 'Left' at all. It is thoroughly
Right-wing when it comes to Wall Street and the Pentagon, even while it
clamours to support sodomy, feminism and a host of other evils. In so many ways
America is an evil empire and in that sense they are right to celebrate the
legacy of John McCain.
If there was any opposition to war coming from the mainstream
media it died with the Vietnam era. PBS even ran a Frontline episode earlier
this year which was all but a paean to McCain and painted him as the sober and
responsible leader, so needed in this age of Trump.
Not only was McCain dangerous, he was reckless. I will for
the moment leave aside his history as an aerial butcher who in my opinion
engenders no sympathy. The fool pushed for war and militarism at almost every
opportunity. I'm convinced he thought of himself as some kind modern Churchill
which to many would be admirable thing but they too suffer from historical
blindness, the weavings of mythology and the false binaries of most modern
political thought. There has also been a real danger in misappropriating the
so-called lessons of Munich in painting every compromise as 'appeasement' and
every foe as 'Hitler'. McCain was deeply guilty of this tendency.
McCain was corrupt. Everyone seems to have forgotten the
financial scandals of the 1980's, an epoch laden with massive fraud and conspiracy,
the tip of a Deep State iceberg to be sure. McCain (one of the Keating Five) so
deeply wed to the military establishment escaped relatively unscathed. His
exoneration by the Senate is itself instructive regarding the good-old-boy
system and how (when it comes to systemic issues) the political-party
factionalism suddenly blurs and becomes meaningless. The Democratically controlled
Ethics Committee whitewashed his deeds. He most certainly was not innocent. While
McCain grumbled about congressional 'pork' his own record of rather dubious
special treatment for donors is as bad as anyone.
McCain also gave us the witch, Sarah Palin, a figure reviled
by the mainstream social order and certainly the media. Why isn't there more
umbrage at this? Why do I call her a witch? She became akin to a prophetess, a
heroine to many Christians even while she abandoned (rebelled against) not only
Christian motherhood but even what historical understandings of motherhood
were. She spun endless lies and manipulations and (along with her apologists) made
a mockery of Christianity. Her understanding of the faith resorts to what can
only be called a type of magic. She was a fool and destructive to all parties
that she came into contact with. Let's hope she never re-enters the public
arena.
But we can thank John McCain for giving her almost a decade
of public influence. This was his astute judgment at work. Right? No, the
episode demonstrated that he was an unprincipled man, an opportunist. His
so-called Maverick or Rogue ideology was little more than letting tactics
govern strategy, the very thing he always harped about.
The media is not Left-wing. As I and many other continually
point out, it's part of the Establishment. Their praise of McCain exemplifies
this. As with many figures his star waxed and waned over the years. On campaign
finance, he was (again ironically given his past) going against the grain.
These relatively weak calls for reform along with his stand against torture are
perhaps the only areas I think him worthy of some accolade. And yet overall
McCain fit in pretty well with the Center and as the nation has become more
polarised the media appreciated him all the more. An ultra-nationalist opposing
Trump, his voice carried particular weight and the media raised his profile.
His 2008 campaign was a disaster by all accounts. He deserves
a great deal of the blame but also he was running on the GOP ticket at an
impossible time. Already I feel like many have forgotten the real public animus
directed toward the Bush administration in the final years of his second term.
McCain tried to distance himself from the administration but it didn't work.
Of course the even greater irony is that Obama ended up
supporting the same Neo-Conservative militarist agenda. His style was different
and McCain and others made much hay over this but in reality they were always
on the same team. The goals were and are the same. The battles are over style
and what mechanisms to use. It's an intramural battle that pretends to be
existential and most of the most of the public falls for it.
If McCain had repented of his participation in the atrocity
that was Vietnam I would have respected him. On the contrary he made it his
career and an essential part of his identity. He used it as a launch-pad to
power which I have always found reprehensible. The more one examines America's
involvement in Indochina the more disgusted one becomes. It was all lies,
manipulation and mass murder. It was a shameful episode and the vast majority
of Americans have not even begun to understand what happened there, what their
country did and how their 'heroes' behaved. The same is true in Korea and yet
these eras have already faded from memory and the myths and legends have been spun.
McCain built a life on this and did rather well for himself. I hope he enjoyed
it because it's the only reward he will ever receive and though the world
honours him, he is now the citizen of a country in which none are honoured or
praised.
As bad as Obama turned out to be I am humanly speaking 'glad'
that McCain never got a chance to be the commander in chief of the US Empire.
Obama is dripping in blood and yet I think things would have taken a much worse
turn under someone like McCain. And then of course Sarah Palin (as
vice-president) would have established a greater credibility and it's likely
she would still be on the scene.
Perhaps the greatest irony of all is that in bringing Palin
to the national stage, McCain unwittingly set off a social and cultural bomb
leading to the Tea Party movement and the rise of Donald Trump. These final
years must have been bitter for John McCain. He had always opposed the
Christian and libertarian elements on the Republican fringe and yet he
unwittingly helped to unleash and empower them, creating our contemporary toxic
brew. To be fair, he cannot be blamed for all of it but the Palin episode
demonstrates a lack of understanding and certainly poor judgment. All men are
flawed in their judgment and every public figure is subject to what are often
large and glaring mistakes and yet McCain is almost unique in that he lived to
see the fruit of his errors.
Can you really say your opening line? Isn't that judging in the sense Jesus meant - i.e. final judgement? I mean, it seems probable on some level, but you never know what happens in someone's final moments.
ReplyDeleteI knew it would put some people off but I see no reason to believe otherwise. God's mercy is beyond our comprehension but in normative terms McCain did not have a credible profession. He like many Americans (and particularly politicians) dabbled with religion but it's clear it never had any real grip on his life. He was pressured to be baptised but refused. Born into Episcopalianism he was baptised as an infant which would be valid enough, but instead of appealing to his paedobaptism he instead attended a Baptist Church and refused baptism as unnecessary. He thus effectively invalidated his infant baptism and yet then refused baptism.
ReplyDeleteBasically looking at his life he seems unrepentant even defiant at times. Is there that slight chance he may have repented at the last hour or maybe even in the last year or whatever? Yes. But where's the fruit of transformation?
A serial adulterer, financially and legally corrupt, a man of blood and yet he never demonstrated any repentance over these things.... worldly repentance perhaps, a kind of pseudo-sorrow and contrition at best.
I don't find some kind of satisfaction in his damnation but at the same time I think (for whatever it's worth) that the stark consequences of life and our decisions needs to be remembered. A warning as it were. That's why I think shocking statements like that need to be voiced. This is not a game. You know that of course. I'm not suggesting otherwise.
The man is being memoralised on a fairly grand scale in both the media and in ceremonies. All this grand remembrance and some Christians are getting caught up in it. A very small number seem to actually remember that back in the 1990s and early 2000's he was considered an enemy, and pretty hostile to many aspects of Conservative Christianity. There were many who were having a fit about his 2008 nomination. That's when he pulled the Palin card and won many of them over.
Do I think he's in hell? I most certainly do. Could I be wrong? Of course. But if he was converted the great tragedy would be that he wasted his last years, months, days and hours and never proclaimed it, never denounced what he'd been part of it, what he'd given his life to if indeed he did so. There was no fruit and thus no reason to accept whatever sort of profession he might have made. At best he was a worshiper at the Dan and Bethel shrines in Israel. I don't think he ever crossed over in Judah.
I agree with much of that - it's just always been my understanding that Jesus' command not to judge means to say for certain where someone's final destination is, even if we might have a probability in mind.
DeleteThat's fair enough. There are times when I should probably be a bit more moderate in my language. I think there are some that we can say, there's very little hope or probability and indeed (as we know) there will be some that die thinking they're bound for glory, and maybe everyone else thought so too.... but it didn't turn out that way.
DeleteAnd there are many more, and I can think of many I have known, that you just don't know. You hope but you're unsure.
I tempered it a bit. Some will still find it offensive but I left the door open a crack.
ReplyDeleteBeat me to it!
DeleteHere's the McCain farewell letter that's been in the newspaper and posted online. I guess some find this moving. To me it's clear....McCain was not a believer in Jesus Christ. His god was America. Of course I also have to chuckle at his 'blood and soil' anti-fascist swipe at Trump. But then the FOX news-Glenn Beck-Coulter-D'Souza-GE Veith-Kevin Swanson sphere won't get it because they insist fascism is left-wing and that Nazi blood and soil finds its equivalent in today's enivironmentalist movement. It's risible.
ReplyDeleteOf course McCain's letter is full of lies, myths and distortions. The letter is in many ways his final self-condemnation---proto
Fellow Americans, that association has meant more to me than any other. I lived and died a proud American. We are citizens of the world’s greatest republic, a nation of ideals, not blood and soil. We are blessed and are a blessing to humanity when we uphold and advance those ideals at home and in the world. We have helped liberate more people from tyranny and poverty than ever before in history, and we have acquired great wealth and power in the progress.
We weaken our greatness when we confuse our patriotism with tribal rivalries that have sown resentment and hatred and violence in all the corners of the globe. We weaken it when we hide behind walls, rather than tear them down; when we doubt the power of our ideals, rather than trust them to be the great force for change they have always been.
We are 325 million opinionated, vociferous individuals. We argue and compete and sometimes even vilify each other in our raucous public debates. But we have always had so much more in common with each other than in disagreement. If only we remember that and give each other the benefit of the presumption that we all love our country, we will get through these challenging times. We will come through them stronger than before, we always do.
Ten years ago I had the privilege to concede defeat in the election for president. I want to end my farewell to you with heartfelt faith in Americans that I felt so powerfully that evening. I feel it powerfully still.
Do not despair of our present difficulties. We believe always in the promise and greatness of America because nothing is inevitable here. Americans never quit, we never surrender, we never hide from history. We make history. Farewell fellow Americans, God bless you, and God bless America.
Wow, that's almost like a parody of what a figure like that would write. Hulk Hogan couldn't have done better.
DeleteFrom https://www.mccain.senate.gov/
ReplyDeleteI hated my enemies even before they held me captive because hate sustained me in my devotion to their complete destruction and helped me overcome the virtuous human impulse to recoil in disgust from what had to be done by my hand. I dropped many bombs in Vietnam, and I wish I could say that they only destroyed military targets. But surely non-combatants were among the casualties. --- John McCain 27April2001
However heady the appeal of a call to arms, however just the cause, we should still shed a tear for all that will be lost when war claims its wages from us. Shed a tear, and then get on with the business of killing our enemies as quickly as we can, and as ruthlessly as we must....
ReplyDeleteWe did not cause this war. Our enemies did, and they are to blame for the deprivations and difficulties it occasions. They are to blame for the loss of innocent life. They are to blame for the geopolitical problems confronting our friends and us. We can help repair the damage of war. But to do so, we must destroy the people who started it. Veterans of war live forever with the memory of war's merciless nature, of the awful things that had to be done by their hand. They did not recoil from their terrible duty because they knew that the freedom they defended was worth dying and killing for. War is a miserable business. Let's get on with it.
From https://www.mccain.senate.gov/
Oct 2001